When You Say You "Feel Fat" — Here's What You're Actually Feeling

A few summers ago I was getting ready for a backyard BBQ with my partner. Nothing fancy — just friends, food, a good evening.

I had two shirts picked out. Both ones I liked. I'd worn them before.

I tried on the first one, looked in the mirror and felt it immediately.

That specific, heavy, deflating feeling.

I feel fat.

I tried the second shirt. Same feeling. I stood there for 45 minutes cycling through options, frustrated, unable to land on anything that felt right.

My partner kept telling me I looked great.

I couldn't hear it.

Eventually I got dressed and went to the BBQ and had a perfectly good time. But that 45 minutes stayed with me — not because it was unusual, but because I recognized it. I'd been there before. A lot of people I work with have been there before.

And I started thinking about what was actually happening in that moment. Because it wasn't really about the shirts.

"Fat" Is Not a Feeling

Here's something I've come to understand after years of having these conversations with clients and with myself:

Feeling "fat" and actually being fat are completely separate experiences. One is a physical description. The other is an emotion that's borrowing a word because the real word is harder to say.

Think about it. "Fat" is a descriptor — like tall, or slow, or strong. It's neutral on its own. But somewhere along the way, for most of us, it got loaded with meaning.

Shame. Failure. Unworthiness. Not-enoughness.

So when something hard surfaces — frustration, anxiety, guilt, grief, feeling out of control — and we can't quite name it or don't want to sit with it, "I feel fat" becomes the shortcut.

It's familiar.

It's a feeling we know how to have, even if it's not the feeling that's actually there.

Standing in front of that mirror before the BBQ, what I was actually feeling was frustration. Specifically — frustration with myself.

I'd spent a few weeks over-indulging at celebrations and I knew it. Nobody forced me. I made those choices. And the mirror was where that accountability landed, uncomfortably.

The frustration was valid. The self-directed anger made sense. But I was calling it "fat" because that was easier to reach for than sitting with the actual feeling underneath it.

What I Hear in the Gym

I've been training people in Edmonton for over 15 years — the majority of them women in their 50s, 60s and 70s. And this comes up alot.

Not always in those exact words. But the same current running underneath.

Someone comes in after a holiday weekend and spends the first ten minutes apologizing for themselves.

Someone steps on a scale and goes quiet in a way that has nothing to do with the number.

Someone says "I just feel so blah about my body right now" and what they actually mean is: I'm stressed, I'm not sleeping, I feel out of control in one area of my life and my body is the thing I'm taking it out on.

The body becomes the target because it's visible.

Because we've been conditioned to believe that if our bodies were just right, the uncomfortable feelings would go away too.

They don't work that way.

The body is rarely the actual problem.

What's Usually Actually Going On

In my experience, when someone tells me they feel bad about their body, there's almost always something else underneath it. Not always the same thing — but something.

Sometimes it's frustration, like mine at the BBQ.

Sometimes it's genuine grief about aging — the body changing in ways that feel like loss, and not knowing how to process that.

Sometimes it's anxiety about health, about independence, about what the next decade looks like.

Sometimes it's shame about consistency — the feeling that you know what you should be doing and you haven't been doing it, and your body is the evidence.

None of those things are "fat." All of them are real. And all of them deserve more than being collapsed into a word that doesn't actually describe what's happening.

The moment you can name what's actually there — frustration, grief, anxiety, shame, loss of control — you can actually start working with it. You can't work with "fat." It's too blunt. It's a door that leads nowhere.

This Doesn't Mean the Physical Doesn't Matter

I want to be clear about something, because this can get misread.

None of this means you shouldn't care about your body. None of this means physical health is irrelevant or that wanting to feel strong and capable in your body is somehow shallow.

It's not.

It's one of the most important things you can invest in — especially in your 50s, 60s and 70s, when the returns on that investment are independence, mobility, energy and quality of life.

What it means is that the emotional relationship with your body — the internal monologue, the guilt cycles, the way a bad mirror moment can derail an entire day — that's worth paying attention to separately. Because if the emotional piece is driving the bus, it'll sabotage the physical work every time.

The most successful clients I've worked with aren't the ones who hated their bodies into change. They're the ones who started showing up for their bodies out of something closer to respect. Not perfection. Not unconditional love every single day. Just — this body is worth investing in, and I'm going to show up for it.

That shift is quieter than motivation. It's also a lot more durable.

What You Can Do With This

Next time you catch yourself saying — or thinking — I feel fat, try pausing for just a second and asking: what am I actually feeling right now?

You might be frustrated. Tired. Overwhelmed.

Disappointed in yourself about something specific.

Anxious about something coming. Grieving something you've lost.

Whatever it is — that's the thing worth addressing. Not by punishing yourself at the gym.

Not by restricting what you eat until the feeling goes away. But by naming it, sitting with it briefly, and then deciding what you actually need.

Sometimes you need rest.

Sometimes you need to move.

Sometimes you need to talk to someone.

Sometimes you just need to get to the BBQ and stop standing in front of the mirror.

Your body is not the problem. It is almost never the problem.

[Book a free intro call →] Here

[Download: 5 Things I Wish Every New Client Over 55 Knew Before We Started →] Here